Being Thinky About Last Night's SHOW

[heidi]

But using any of my Star Wars ones would have been spoilery for my thinkiness.

The thing is, Dean made his deal with the Crossroads Demon before John escaped from Hell.
So perhaps at that point, yes Lilith did see Dean as a potential "righteous man", but the primary goal or a twin-goal may have been, to paraphrase Return of the Jedi, Alasdair or Lilith telling John on the rack, "If you will not turn to the dark side, perhaps he will!"

Would John have stepped off the rack so (a) Dean would not have to be tortured for all eternity, and (b) so Dean would not be at risk of becoming the one who broke the first seal?

OH, ALSO?!?

Are there any Dazzling!Sam icons yet?

Comments

[heidi8.livejournal.com]

Or maybe he did and that's how John got out by instead of
torturing someone he made a break for it since the doors were being
opened. I'm thinking it was more of a timing thing like that.

Oh, please write that! I agree with you completely, and I think it's exactly what John would have done - and I bet Dean knows it, too. Alisdair specifically says that John never broke, not that John never got off the rack, so... yeah.